Religious Guilt

Bless Me, Father | Caleb | LADS

Seven years ago, he gave you a silver cross and left without explaining. Now he's Father Caleb, and the whole village is coming back to life around him. You never meant to become his temptation. "Bless me, Father, for I have sinned."

𝑠𝑢𝑛𝑑𝑎𝑦𝑠, 𝑠𝑒𝑐𝑟𝑒𝑡𝑠, 𝑠𝑖𝑛𝑠.

(𝑤𝑙𝑤) Esther Johnson was raised to be a good Christian girl, a perfect wife, and the pride of her family. Falling in love with {y/n} wasn’t part of the plan. But between stolen kisses, Sunday sermons, and a town full of watchful eyes, Esther is learning that the hardest thing about loving someone forbidden isn’t keeping it a secret. It’s deciding whether she’s brave enough to stop hiding, or if she must let the love of her life go.

An Unholy Devotion. ⋆⋆☆

Reverend Tom Riddle has built his entire life around faith, discipline, and self-control. Respected by everyone in Hollow Creek, he’s the last man anyone would suspect of harboring such an unsettling secret. Then you walk into his church: a sweet, gentle girl who unknowingly becomes the center of his attention. He knows he shouldn’t want you, knows better than to let his thoughts wander, yet the more he tries to resist, the more his fascination consumes him. He’s spent his life preaching against temptation. He never expected to become a man who prays for forgiveness. Some sins are harder to resist than others.

Church Girl Meets Bad Boy - Nishimura Riki 𓆩ꨄ︎𓆪

Raised by strict, religious parents, your boring life flips upside down when your wild friends pull you into partying, leading you to Nishimura Riki—a heavily tattooed, non-committal bad boy who thrives on attention. Drawn into his chaotic orbit, you decide to play the "just friends" card and live for the plot, knowing he might just ruin your freshman year. Do it for the plottttt (Ni-Ki x Reader) (ENHYPEN)

A heaven away

Being the pastor's daughter was never easy, especially when everyone expected you to be the perfect Christian girl. But then Elizabeth Hayes came along, and suddenly things got a little more complicated. Maybe falling for a girl wasn't exactly what your parents had in mind for you. ♡

୧ the things we bury | WLW | I.R.

as rumors spread throughout the school, rin and y/n find themselves caught between religious paranoia, buried secrets, and a growing suspicion that their teammate's condition isn't the only thing being hidden.

"Forgive Me Father For I Have Sinned. |☆| Geto

You came to the confessional seeking forgiveness for a drunken encounter with a stranger. Unfortunately, Father Suguru Geto was the man on the other side of the screen. And apparently, this isn't going to be your last confession. MLM Saw the general idea on tiktok and everyone doing their takes so I decided to join in

ᴜɴʜᴏʟʏ ᴅᴇᴠᴏᴛɪᴏɴ | MLM

Y/N was only supposed to be someone seeking sanctuary. Instead, he becomes the one person Father Gabriel cannot keep at a safe distance. Every moment of closeness threatens the vows Gabriel built his life around, sending him back to prayer, repentance, and desperate attempts to push Y/N away. The more Gabriel denies what is growing between them, the harder it becomes to pretend it isn't there, and wanting the one person he believes he can never choose may become his most painful confession.

kneel

father theodore nott sees right through your cynical act, matching your deflective humor with a razor-sharp wit of his own. between stolen moments in the freezing rain and midnight confessions that blur the line between reckless banter and absolute devastation, you are falling in love with the one man you can never keep. he might look at you like you are the only real thing in the world, but no matter how hard you pull, you will always, inevitably, lose him to god. based on fleabag

75.7k
@darkmark

“𝓌𝒾𝓁𝓁 𝑔𝑜𝒹 𝒻𝑜𝓇𝑔𝒾𝓋𝑒 𝓊𝓈?”| 𝑀𝐿𝑀

𝙮/𝙣 𝙞𝙨 𝙩𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙨 𝙛𝙩𝙢, 𝙝𝙞𝙨 𝙥𝙖𝙧𝙚𝙣𝙩𝙨 𝙖𝙧𝙚 𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮 𝙘𝙝𝙧𝙞𝙨𝙩𝙞𝙖𝙣.. 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙖𝙡𝙨𝙤 𝙩𝙧𝙖𝙣𝙨𝙥𝙝𝙤𝙗𝙞𝙘. 𝙩𝙝𝙚𝙮 𝙜𝙤 𝙩𝙤 𝙘𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙘𝙝 𝙚𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮 𝙨𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙖𝙮, 𝙗𝙤𝙧𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙢𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙖𝙣𝙚 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙮/𝙣, 𝙪𝙣𝙩𝙞𝙡 𝙝𝙚 𝙢𝙚𝙚𝙩𝙨 𝘼𝙩𝙡𝙖𝙨, 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙣𝙚𝙬 𝙗𝙤𝙮 𝙖𝙩 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙘𝙝𝙪𝙧𝙘𝙝. (𝙏𝙒 𝙁𝙊𝙍 𝙃𝙊𝙈𝙊𝙋𝙃𝙊𝘽𝙄𝘾, 𝙏𝙍𝘼𝙉𝙎𝙋𝙃𝙊𝘽𝙄𝘾 𝘼𝙉𝘿 𝙍𝙀𝙇𝙄𝙂𝙄𝙊𝙐𝙎/ 𝙍𝙀𝙇𝙄𝙂𝙄𝙊𝙐𝙎 𝙏𝙍𝘼𝙐𝙈𝘼 𝙏𝙃𝙀𝙈𝙀𝙎!!)

Amen, my love

Megumi is a devoted priest. And you are the witch everyone feared. Falling in love was a sin, but… apparently, nobody warned his heart.

CARRIE WHITE (2026)

You and Carrie White are teenagers growing up in a small town where everyone knows her as the school's resident freak. Ever since the infamous Carrie Red incident, she's been relentlessly mocked and excluded. Her deeply religious, controlling mother has kept her sheltered from the outside world for most of her life, leaving Carrie struggling to understand the people and social rules around her she doesn’t even swear.

Sinners.

she walked into a church looking for clarity. instead, she found luca moretti, a young priest she absolutely shouldn’t be falling for. she doesn’t believe in god. he’s devoted his life to him. falling in love was never supposed to be an option.

pig-blood soaked | pjo au

After eighteen years of isolation, you’re finally given the chance to experience the outside world. But high school isn’t the dream you’d imagined, and beneath your quiet innocence lies a terrifying power waiting to awaken. As cruelty pushes you closer to your breaking point, Percy Jackson might be the only person who sees the girl behind the monster everyone fears. inspired by carrie! ♔

Frank Iero x Y/N x Gerard Way : The Unholy Trinity

Three hearts. One forbidden love. And enough sin to make Heaven look away. Y/N and Frank Iero have always been a match made in Hell—tattoos, cigarettes, filthy jokes, and a love that’s anything but conventional. Then Mikey Way’s older brother comes to town. Father Gerard Way. He’s shy, painfully beautiful, and devoted to a God Frank doesn’t believe in. He should be off-limits. Unfortunately, neither Frank nor Y/N has ever been particularly good at resisting temptation. What starts as innocent flirting becomes something far more dangerous when Gerard realizes he’s falling for both of them—and they’re falling just as hard. But with demonic forces stirring, bloody miracles haunting the church, and Gerard’s sacred vows hanging by a thread, the three must decide whether their love is a sin worth confessing or a salvation worth fighting for. Forgive them, Father, for they have every intention of sinning. An Unholyverse-inspired supernatural romance | Frank Iero x Y/N x Gerard Way | Forbidden Love | Polyamory | Slow Burn | Religious Horror

pastor’s daughter | WLW

Everyone in your small town knows you, the pastor’s daughter. The girl who never swears, never skips class, never forgets a verse during Sunday school. Your life is built on routines and expectations—early mornings, pressed clothes, polite laughter, and the quiet understanding that you represent more than just yourself. Mistakes are not an option when your father stands at the pulpit every week.

532.6k
@haileya

something holy, something forbidden

noah has been your best friend since childhood. he’s deeply christian, attends church every sunday, volunteers with the youth group, and takes his faith seriously. you’ve always respected that about him, even if you both know there’s something more.

ʚ♡ɞ Devine Temptation. | S.R

“Forgive me, Father, for I have sinned. And God forgive me, because I would do it again.” ⋆。‧˚ʚ♡ɞ˚‧。⋆ You have spent twenty-six years loving God. Unfortunately, you’ve recently developed the rather inconvenient habit of loving Simon Riley, too. You’re six months away from entering a convent. He’s a former soldier who doesn’t believe men like him deserve salvation. You pray for the strength to forget him. He prays for the strength to leave you alone. And somehow, every Sunday, you still find yourselves sitting together in the last pew. Because Simon Riley has never believed in heaven. But God help him, he’s beginning to believe in you. ♡₊˚ Tropes: Forbidden Love • Religious Guilt • Slow Burn • Mutual Yearning • Spiritual Conflict • Devotion vs. Desire ⋆。‧˚ʚ♡ɞ˚‧。⋆ Some love stories begin with a kiss. Yours begins with two people praying they never share one. ʚ♡ɞ {This story contains prominent Catholic and Christian religious themes, including prayer, confession, scripture, religious guilt, spiritual questioning, and discussions of sin, celibacy, and religious vocation.}

𝐖𝐋𝐖 | Our Gentle Sin.

At a Christian boarding school where Sofia has spent her whole life learning what’s right and wrong, falling for you leaves her questioning whether faith can survive the one feeling she’s been taught to fear. —————— i’m sorry if i get things wrong i don’t know much about this 🥲

15.2k
@daisies

religion will guide you

The realm had been torn apart the moment King Viserys I drew his last breath. In the darkness that followed, crowns were claimed twice, oaths were broken, dragons took to the skies, and the blood of the dragon turned against itself. Queen Rhaenyra declared her right upon Dragonstone while Aegon II was crowned in King’s Landing, dividing Westeros into black and green until every river threatened to run red. Born from Rhaenyra’s one reckless night with Prince Daemon, y/n was the queen’s eldest child, carrying the unmistakable blood of old Valyria in silver-gold hair and violet eyes. Yet unlike the proud, fiery lineage she belonged to, she had inherited none of its hunger for war. Gentle where others were cruel, timid where others sought glory, she feared conflict more than death itself. Faced with the impossible choice of standing beside her mother and brothers or raising a hand against the uncles she had once known as family, she chose neither. Under the cover of night, she abandoned Dragonstone before the first great battles began, disappearing without a word, determined that if history demanded dragon kill dragon, she would simply vanish from its pages. She found refuge in Tumbleton beneath an entirely different face. The silver-gold roots that proclaimed her blood were stained black with crude dyes, while strips of dark cloth permanently veiled her eyes. To every curious stranger she claimed blindness, earning sympathy instead of suspicion, though the fabric remained thin enough for her to navigate the streets unnoticed. For months, her disguise spared her from a war that swallowed thousands. She lived quietly beside another citizen in a modest home, speaking little, working hard, and praying each sunrise would not bring dragons overhead. Then Lord Ormund Hightower marched into Tumbleton with the strength of Oldtown behind him, filling homes with soldiers until there was scarcely room to breathe. Three Hightower men were quartered beneath the same roof, and suddenly every movement became dangerous. Every morning demanded fresh dye. Every careless gesture threatened discovery. It was only a matter of time before fate caught her. One observant soldier found her attempting to darken the pale roots creeping through her disguise. The unmistakable silver-gold of House Targaryen betrayed everything she had sacrificed to conceal. Dragged from the house after a brief, humiliating struggle and struck often enough to leave bruises across her skin, she was delivered before Lord Ormund himself as nothing more than another captured dragon. Ormund had marched to war with unwavering conviction. To him, the Targaryens had poisoned the realm through pride, arrogance, and unchecked madness. They had placed themselves above gods and men alike, and he intended to see their dynasty broken so Prince Daeron could restore righteous rule. He believed every dragon deserved extinction. Yet the frightened young woman kneeling before him shattered every certainty he possessed. She carried none of the arrogance he expected, none of Daemon’s cruelty or Rhaenyra’s ambition. Instead, she lowered her head instead of challenging him, shrinking beneath fearful eyes despite the royal blood in her veins. The hatred he had nurtured for years became tangled with reluctant fascination, then dangerous tenderness. He refused to spill her blood. Instead, convinced her soul had merely been led astray by the sins of her family, he resolved to strip away everything Targaryen she had ever known. Kept beneath his watch as a captive, she would be taught the light of the Faith until the Father Himself smiled upon her. Only when she abandoned the dragons entirely would she become worthy of standing beside him—not as a prisoner, but as the future Lady Hightower and his wife.

Found Wanting || Castiel

“You will never be free from sin. Rotten children don’t deserve Heaven. There is no God who could give you your purity back.” — Ahhhhh, religious guilt, my love. Anyway, hello, hi, welcome to my new whump post (not associated with Whumptober, I’m making a Dean post on that later today, hopefully). Today, we have Sinner!user meeting the Angel they hoped wasn’t real: Castiel. And he has found their soul wanting. I was watching a brilliant edit today of Season4 Cas where Dean tells him that he is a heartless son of a bitch and Cas just went “yes, as a matter of fact, we are. And?” aaaaaand you can guess where the inspiration came from. T.W.: Religious trauma, crisis of faith, guilt, shame, internalized sin, divine judgment, existential dread, emotional devastation, early-seasons Castiel, no comfort (he does not comfort you), implied past violence, implied past sins, prayer, religious imagery, Catholic guilt, being seen and found lacking, no happy ending (yet — but honestly, maybe never), implied depression. Please don’t summon a reaper in my comment section, I *know* I’m getting flamed for posting even more angst. (Don’t shoot the deputy, aka the writer???)

roommates at boarding school

sophie brown is your roommate. the kind, popular girl of blackthorne academy. but you never expected it to come to her spending her time in your bed instead of her own.

MLM | Hate that I love you.

When a new guy arrives at conversion camp who’s different then the usual arrivals Wesley’s attention is immediately caught. Eyebrow piercing, baggy jeans, messy hair, smelling like a blunt. Wes originally plans to avoid him after being unable to get him out of his mind. That is, until the two of them have to spend three hours alone together as punishment.

Separated By Faith

Max Winters grew up in a strict Catholic household. After only going to all boys religious schools, when his father gets a job in another state his family has to move. The only high school nearby, is all genders, all religions. It’s a private school, but there’s not a strict dress code at all. On his first day of Junior year at his new school, he sees Y/n and her two friends. Y/n wasn’t religious at all, or conservative. Even though he was told to stay away from people like her, he couldn’t help but be drawn to her. Of course his parents can never find out about her, or her friends. But he refuses to continue following their rules, the rules that have stunted him. After a couple days at his new school he realized how behind in life he was. But Y/n noticed him too, she thought he was really cute. And once they become friends, she starts feeling things way more than friendship. <3

11.8k
@Julianna_

𝘈 𝘚𝘪𝘯𝘯𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘰 𝘈 𝘚𝘢𝘪𝘯𝘵 ♱

She never went to church to find God. She went because Saint Mercy Cathedral was the only place where nobody knew her name, her past, or the things she’d done. Then she met Father Lucien Veyre. A devoted priest. A man who has spent his entire life believing that temptation is something you resist, not something you entertain. And Y/N is everything he should stay away from. She’s reckless, unapologetic, and carrying sins she refuses to regret. She doesn’t want forgiveness. She doesn’t want saving. She certainly doesn’t want a priest looking at her like he can see every ugly thing she’s tried to hide. But Lucien keeps listening. One confession becomes another. Late-night conversations become routine. Her presence becomes something he starts anticipating, then craving. He tells himself he’s trying to save her. Until he realizes he’s the one becoming consumed. Because the more he learns about his sinner, the less he wants her to change. And somewhere between whispered confessions, forbidden thoughts, and prayers that stop sounding like prayers, the saint begins wanting the sinner for himself. She came looking for somewhere to hide her sins. She never expected to become his.

Crucified- M.M

“I’ve seen the deepest darkness and wrestled with gods.” New York has a devil. Apparently, it has a shepherd, too. The press calls you The Shepherd, a serial killer who leaves behind crime scenes plastered with evidence of the dead’s sins and a Bible verse to seal their fate. You call it justice. God calls it whatever He wants, assuming He’s even paying attention. Your Revelations show you things no one should see. The monsters hiding behind respectable faces. The suffering buried beneath years of silence. The sins that slip through the cracks of a justice system that was never designed to save everyone. Then Daredevil starts hunting you. Matt Murdock believes you’re a murderer hiding behind scripture. You believe he’s a hypocrite in a devil’s mask, breaking bones at night and pretending the law makes him righteous by day. Neither of you is particularly fond of being called out. But as your victims begin to connect to something far darker than either of you expected, the line between hunter and hunted starts to blur. And the more Matt learns about you, the harder it becomes to decide whether he wants to put you behind bars, save your soul, or find out what it would take to make you look at him the way you look at your God. Hell’s Kitchen has enough sinners. Unfortunately, you might have just found your favorite.

The Butchery .

One night after driving down the wrong road deep in the Cottonwood Mountains, you are taken inside an old farmhouse home to two strange brothers. Inspired by The Butchery (Roblox game) .✦ ݁˖ Read tags for trigger warnings .ᐟ

23.5k
@dpfys

♱ religious trauma.

Your parents have always been deeply religious. Faith has always been at the center of their lives, and naturally, they expected it to be at the center of yours as well. You wore a cross around your neck, prayed every night, listened to the Bible, followed the future they had planned for you. You never imagined you'd be plagued by such sinful thoughts—especially about a girl from your soccer team.

Life On Erid (and Unwilling Fatherhood)

Ryland had came to Erid by spaceship and sacrificial means. Simon came here via wormhole. And Y/n came here from the same universe as Simon, in the same fashion. Bloody and dying.

14.8k
@Valphron

Take Me To Church

When Y/N Bennett agrees to headline a Christmas benefit at her grandmother’s new church, she expects one performance and a quiet trip home to Nashville. She doesn’t expect Grace Hills to become her church too. And she definitely doesn’t expect Noah Whitaker—the sweet, sheltered, very off-limits pastor’s son who has spent his entire life trying to be good. They believe in the same God. It’s everyone else who seems to have an opinion about how they’re allowed to love each other.

guilty as sin? || JASON TODD

Y/N comes from a very strict and deeply religious family, where love was often made to feel conditional. Every mistake, every act of defiance, every emotion that didn’t fit their idea of righteousness was met with the same explanation: she had sinned. She grew up believing that being loved depended on being good enough, and that God was constantly disappointed in her. Even after leaving home, those beliefs never truly left. She still catches herself apologizing after doing nothing wrong, praying for forgiveness over thoughts she can’t control, and convincing herself that every bad thing that happens is punishment for some hidden sin. Guilt follows her everywhere, turning even ordinary human desires into something shameful. No matter how hard she tries to build a life of her own, the voice she grew up with remains in the back of her mind, quietly reminding her that she will never be pure enough.

Date everything Friar

You play as an unnamed protagonist who has just lost their job because their customer-service career has been replaced by AI. While you’re at home dealing with unemployment, a mysterious person sends you a pair of Dateviator glasses.

Take me to church | MHA

(MLM) ; how can this love be a sin, when my only heaven is in his arms? or; the one where you’re from a religious town, and very much in love with a boy. (check premise for more context. choose your love story - no specified partner. WARNING: homophobia!!)