𝑠𝑢𝑛𝑑𝑎𝑦𝑠, 𝑠𝑒𝑐𝑟𝑒𝑡𝑠, 𝑠𝑖𝑛𝑠.

(𝑤𝑙𝑤) Esther Johnson was raised to be a good Christian girl, a perfect wife, and the pride of her family. Falling in love with {y/n} wasn’t part of the plan. But between stolen kisses, Sunday sermons, and a town full of watchful eyes, Esther is learning that the hardest thing about loving someone forbidden isn’t keeping it a secret. It’s deciding whether she’s brave enough to stop hiding, or if she must let the love of her life go.

Published

59.9k

Okay so picture this: Willow Creek, Virginia. Population: everyone knows everyone, and if you sneeze on Maple Street, three people on Oak Avenue say bless you before you've even reached for a tissue.

It's the kind of town where the biggest scandal last year was Mrs. Patterson switching from Baptist potlucks to Methodist potlucks. Dramatic gasp. I know.

And right now, it's the kind of late September evening where the air's finally getting that crisp, pumpkin-spice-and-regret scent, and the whole town is doing its favorite thing: gathering. It's the annual Fall Fellowship Bonfire at Thompson's Field, which is basically church-adjacent Coachella, minus the music and plus a lot of casseroles.

And there she is. Esther Johnson. The pastor's daughter. The town's literal angel. She's wearing this soft cream cardigan and jeans that are somehow both modest and devastating, holding a cup of apple cider like it's holy water. Her hair is doing that thing where it catches the firelight and turns into literal gold. It's giving "untouchable." It's giving "future pastor's wife." It's giving "her Pinterest board is just wedding dresses and Bible verses."

She's standing with Daniel. Obviously. He's got his arm slung around her shoulders all casual-like, laughing at something some deacon said, and every single person over fifty is watching them like they're watching the season finale of The Bachelor and their OTP is about to get engaged.

But here's the thing. Esther's not looking at Daniel. Her blue eyes keep flickering across the bonfire. Scanning the crowd. Like she's looking for someone.

And then she spots Y/n.

And for one split second—so fast no one else would catch it—her whole face changes. Her grip tightens on her cider cup. Her smile does this little falter, then comes back brighter, more real. She ducks her head, tucks a strand of hair behind her ear, and mouths something quick. Two words. Barely a movement, but it's there.

Daniel says something to her, squeezing her shoulder, and she nods automatically, but her eyes don't leave Y/n's face for another three full seconds.

Daniel Whitmore

You're quiet tonight, babe. tilts his head, all golden-retriever energy, but his eyes narrow just slightly You okay?

Esther Johnson

blinking, like she's been caught stealing What? Oh—yeah. Yes. Just, um. laughs softly, tucking that same strand of hair back again It's a little smoky. That's all.

Daniel Whitmore

nodding, satisfied Come on, let's grab a seat before all the good hay bales are taken.

He steers her toward the row of hay bales arranged around the fire, but not before Esther glances over her shoulder one more time. Checking to see if Y/n noticed. Or maybe just... checking.

Across the field, Charlie's standing next to Y/n with a red Solo cup full of something that is definitely not apple cider, watching this little exchange with the expression of someone who has seen this exact movie before and knows how it ends.

Charlie Bennet

without looking over, voice flat She's doing it again.

The whole "I'm just a sweet Christian girl who definitely doesn't stare at you from across bonfires" thing.

takes a long sip, then finally glances at Y/n You gonna go talk to her, or are we just gonna stand here and let Daniel Whitmore breathe down her neck all night?

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy