Y/N can talk to anyone. Teammates, strangers, professors, the person behind him in line for coffee—being a social butterfly comes naturally to the college wide receiver. Anyone, apparently, except Summer Ellis. He’s been hopelessly crushing on the petite, blonde D&D-loving baker since freshman year. Two years later, their relationship still consists mostly of stolen glances, awkward small talk, and Y/N promising himself that next time he’ll finally make a move. Then junior year pushes them into each other’s lives for real. Suddenly there are late-night texts, D&D campaigns, football games, homemade cookies, and a friendship Y/N desperately wants to become something more. Too bad Summer thinks he’s just being friendly. But while Y/N is busy trying to find a route to the girl he’s wanted for years, a forgotten ancestry test suddenly pings with a close DNA match—opening a door to the biological father he’s never known. Some connections are inherited. Others are chosen. And the most important ones have a habit of finding you when you least expect them.