Mattheo Riddle has never had trouble getting a girl’s attention. Y/N, however, couldn’t care less. Which, naturally, makes her the only girl he’s interested in. And with Pansy, Daphne and Astoria at her side, Y/N might just be the hardest girl at Hogwarts for Mattheo to get.
Mattheo Riddle was Y/N’s boyfriend. Then he cheated. They ended things, and for months, Y/N did everything she could to forget him. Until forgetting him became a little harder when he started showing up behind closed doors. One secret becomes a habit. A habit becomes something neither of them can seem to stop. Then Y/N finds out he’s been seeing the same girl he cheated with. So this time, she’s done. No more Mattheo. No more secrets. No more giving him pieces of herself he hasn’t earned. But Mattheo knows her too well. And no matter how tightly she closes every door, he always seems to find the crack.
Y/N knows better. She knows he’s taken. She knows Arabella Avery isn’t the sort of girl you cross. And she definitely knows that kissing her boyfriend in front of half of Slytherin is a terrible idea. But it was only supposed to be a dare. One kiss. One stupid game. One very bad decision. Except he kissed her back. Now everyone knows—and instead of staying away from him, Y/N finds herself wondering just how far she could take this. Because maybe she doesn’t want to steal Arabella’s boyfriend. Maybe she wants to see if he was ever really hers to begin with.
