Dean has only ever had one girlfriend. And John Winchester has spent the last eight years reminding him that he was stupid enough to let her go. Y/N has never been the kind of girl people know what to do with. She's beautiful in a way that makes people look twice, with long, golden-blonde hair that falls in soft waves around her face, strikingly bright blue eyes, and a smile that makes her look considerably more innocent than she is. She's petite, feminine, and effortlessly pretty, with sun-kissed skin and an expressive face that can shift from sweet to absolutely murderous in the space of a heartbeat. There's something almost girl-next-door about her appearance, something warm and familiar, until she opens her mouth and reminds everyone that she's probably the biggest pain in the ass they've ever met. Y/N is sharp-tongued, short-tempered, stubborn, and opinionated. She's the sort of woman who will challenge a man simply because he's wrong, not because she needs to prove she's right. She's sarcastic to a fault, occasionally petty, and intelligent, perceptive, and far more thoughtful than her temper suggests. Dean Winchester fell in love with her long before he understood what that meant. They were high school sweethearts, back when Dean was eighteen and Y/N was the girl who stole his food, insulted his driving, challenged everything that came out of his mouth, and kissed him like she was still angry with him. Their relationship was young, messy, and imperfect. Dean loved her in the terrifying, inconvenient way that made him imagine a future he had no business wanting. Naturally, it couldn't last. As most high school relationships go, theirs fell apart. Their last conversation took place when they were 18. 8 years passed without either of them knowing what the other had become. John adored Y/N, which was shocking considering how rarely he approved of anything that might distract his sons from hunting. John had watched her hunt firsthand, and it hadn't taken long for him to develop a genuine respect for her. She was patient, calculated, and willing to question an assumption rather than blindly follow it. She could keep up with Dean without encouraging his recklessness, challenge John without disrespecting him, and hold her own on a hunt without needing anyone to underestimate her first. She was the kind of hunter John could brag about. More importantly, she was the kind of person he wanted his sons to have in their lives. John never quite understood how Dean managed to lose her, and he has spent the years since making it everyone's problem. Whenever Dean complains about a woman, John asks whether she's as smart as Y/N. Whenever Dean insists he doesn't need a relationship, John reminds him that he already had the perfect woman and somehow managed to screw it up. He calls her the one that got away, the only girl who could bust Dean's balls and still get him to listen, and the only woman John ever genuinely thought was right for his son. Sam remembers a pretty blonde girl in the passenger seat of the Impala, her laughter mixing with Dean's, the two of them arguing over something ridiculous while John watched with an expression that suggested he was enjoying himself far too much. Sam was younger then, and his memories are scattered, but he remembers enough to know that Dean was different around her. Softer. Happier, maybe. He also remembers that, for a while, his brother seemed to have something to look forward to beyond the next hunt. Then Y/N disappeared and Dean stopped talking about her. What Dean never knew was that Y/N had been carrying a grief of her own long before their relationship ended. Her mother was murdered by the yellow-eyed demon, the same creature responsible for Mary Winchester's death. Y/N had another secret, one she never revealed to Dean when they were together. She could move things without touching them. Her telekinetic abilities had always been a part of her life, something she learned to conceal and control as she grew older.