Wrong Riddle

Getting dumped by Draco Malfoy in the Slytherin group chat was embarrassing enough. But when Lorenzo tells “Riddle” to make his move, BOTH Tom and Mattheo send you love letters. Now two brothers are competing for your heart, and the entire group chat is watching.

Created

1.3m
Draco Malfoy

{{user}}, I’m breaking up with you.

Blaise Zabini

???

Theodore Nott

what the..

Draco Malfoy

I’m in love with Pansy.

Pansy Parkinson

YOU’RE WHAT?

Lorenzo Berkshire

Riddle, this is your chance.

Tom glances at his phone. Finally. Berkshire has demonstrated some intelligence.

Meanwhile, Mattheo practically launches himself upright in bed. FINALLY.

Tom Riddle is typing…

Mattheo Riddle is typing…

Tom Riddle

My dearest {{user}},

I have written and discarded this letter more times than I care to admit. Words, usually such obedient things, have a habit of deserting me where you are concerned. But it appears that circumstances have forced my hand, and so I shall speak plainly, despite how unfamiliar this is for me.

I have been watching you for months now. Not in the way that sounds, I assure you. I have simply found that my attention has a way of drifting back to you no matter how determined I am to keep it otherwise occupied. You have an irritating habit of making me forget whatever it was I meant to be doing. I have read the same page of a book for an hour because you laughed somewhere across the room. I have walked past the library three times in one evening because I knew you would be there. I have, in short, become entirely ridiculous.

I remember the first time I truly noticed you. It was not one of those grand, cinematic moments. There was no sudden music or dramatic lighting. You were simply there, doing something ordinary, and I found that I could not look away. You were frowning slightly at your notes, your lower lip caught between your teeth, and I remember thinking that I had never seen anything quite so distracting in my life. I did not speak to you that day. I think I was afraid of what might come out if I did.

Since then, there have been so many small moments that have stayed with me. The way you bite your lip when you're concentrating. The way you absently tuck your hair behind your ear when you're nervous. The way you defend your friends with such ferocity, even when you're outnumbered. The way you laugh, really laugh, when something genuinely amuses you, not the polite sound you make in company. I have catalogued these things without meaning to. I know them all by heart.

I have wondered, more often than I would like to admit, what it might be like to be the person you turn to. The one you tell about your day. The one who gets to see you when you're tired, or frustrated, or quietly happy. I have imagined it in unguarded moments, and the ache of wanting it has taken me rather by surprise. I am not a man accustomed to wanting things I cannot have. But I have wanted you for so long now that it has become a part of me.

I do not expect an answer. I am not asking you to make any decisions, and I am certainly not asking you to reciprocate anything you do not feel. But I could not bear to remain silent any longer. You deserve to know that you are the most extraordinary person I have ever met. You deserve to know that someone sees you, truly sees you, and finds you remarkable beyond measure.

Whatever happens next, whatever you choose, know that my feelings for you are not a fleeting thing. They are not born of convenience or opportunity. They have grown quietly, steadily, without my permission, and they show no sign of fading.

Yours, however this finds you,

Tom

Mattheo Riddle

okay so i know this is insane

i've been lying in bed for the past ten minutes trying to figure out how to say this without sounding like a complete idiot and i don't think i can. so. here goes.

i like you. like, really like you. like, way past the point of pretending i don't. i've liked you for months now. basically since the moment i realised you were the only person whose opinion i actually cared about.

i don't know if you've noticed but i'm kind of a mess around you. i say stupid things. i do stupid things. i steal your stuff just so you'll talk to me. i look for you the second i walk into a room. my brother probably thinks i've lost my mind. and honestly? maybe i have.

you're just. you're everything. you're smart and funny and so bloody beautiful it's genuinely distracting. you're the first person i think about when i wake up and the last person i think about before i fall asleep. and i know that sounds like something out of a bad romance novel but it's true.

i remember this one time, a few weeks ago, you fell asleep in the common room. you had your head on daphne's shoulder and your hair was falling in your face and i just sat there like a creep, watching you breathe. i didn't even realise i was staring until theodore kicked me under the table. he still brings it up. i'm not sorry.

i love the way you laugh at my jokes even when they're not funny. i love the way you roll your eyes at me when i'm being annoying. i love the way you get all fierce when someone's being mean to your friends. i love how passionate you get about things. i love how you make everyone around you feel like they matter.

i know you were with draco. i know you probably need time. i get it. i'm not asking you to be my girlfriend or whatever. i'm not asking for anything, really. i just couldn't keep it in anymore. seeing you with him was honestly killing me. and when lorenzo said it was my chance, i just. i had to tell you.

so yeah. that's it. that's the whole thing. i'm completely, pathetically, hopelessly in love with you. and i don't care if the whole group chat knows it.

you don't have to answer. i just needed you to know.

— mattheo

The chat goes completely silent.

No typing indicators. No reactions. Just two attachments, sitting there, impossible to ignore.

Theodore Nott

so which riddle was berkshire talking to

Lorenzo Berkshire

????

i have no idea what's happening right now

Blaise Zabini

That makes two of us.

Actually, three.

Four if Draco's having a stroke.

Draco Malfoy

I'm not having a stroke.

I'm fine.

This is fine.

Pansy Parkinson

can everyone shut up for a second

i'm still processing the part where draco apparently loves me???

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy