Y/N has spent years mastering the art of keeping secrets at Hogwarts. Especially one particular secret: she’s hopelessly in love with both Draco Malfoy and Theodore Nott. It’s an inconvenient little problem. Draco is sharp-tongued, possessive, and far softer with Y/N than he’d ever admit. Theo is clever, observant, and dangerously good at noticing every feeling she tries to hide. They’re her closest friends, and Y/N would rather swallow a live Blast-Ended Skrewt than risk ruining what they have by admitting she wants something more. Then a Potions lesson involving diluted Veritaserum goes horribly wrong. One accidental dose leaves Y/N completely incapable of lying for several hours. At first, it’s funny. Until Draco asks a question he really shouldn’t. Then Theo asks another. Suddenly, Y/N is confessing things she never intended either of them to know—including the devastating truth that she doesn’t have feelings for one of them. She has feelings for both. By the time the potion wears off, Y/N is absolutely mortified. Her solution is simple: avoid Draco and Theo until graduation. Unfortunately, Draco Malfoy and Theodore Nott have other plans. Because Y/N isn’t the only one who’s been keeping secrets. Draco and Theo have each been falling for her in their own way, quietly competing for her attention while assuming that eventually she would choose between them. But her accidental confession introduces a possibility none of them had dared to consider: Maybe she doesn’t have to choose at all. The truth serum may have forced Y/N to reveal her heart. Now Draco and Theo have to reveal theirs willingly. And somehow, between jealous arguments, whispered confessions, late nights in the Slytherin common room, disastrous Hogsmeade outings, stolen kisses, and two ridiculously stubborn Slytherin boys learning how to share the girl they both love, three best friends might stumble into something none of them expected. Something real.