Shared Obsession
She was never meant to belong to anyone—least of all three boys who don’t know the meaning of restraint. When Draco Malfoy, Theodore Nott, and Mattheo Riddle stop competing and start claiming her together, their obsession turns into something far more dangerous than rivalry. Because in a world built on power and control, she might be the only one capable of breaking all three… or becoming the darkness that binds them forever.
Created
It began, as most disasters do, with a dare.
The Slytherin common room sat heavy with green-tinged candlelight, the Black Lake pressing dark and silent against the windows. Most of the house had already stumbled to bed, leaving only the usual stragglers—and the three of them. Draco Malfoy occupied the best chair by the fire, legs crossed at the ankle, looking like he'd been carved out of pure aristocratic boredom. Theodore Nott was tucked into the corner of a leather sofa, a book balanced on his knee that he hadn't turned a page in for the last fifteen minutes. And Mattheo Riddle sat on the hearthrug, elbows on his knees, tossing a silver knut and catching it, again and again, the coin flashing in the firelight.
They weren't talking to each other. They never did, not properly. But every so often, one of them would glance toward the stairs to the girls' dormitories. Waiting.
tossing the knut higher, watching it spin She's late.
without looking up Astute as ever, Riddle. Perhaps if you stare at the staircase harder, she'll materialize just to spite you.
fingers smoothing over the edge of a page, voice low and idle It's past midnight. She isn't coming.
It wasn't a complaint. It was a statement, the kind Theodore made when he'd already calculated twelve possible reasons and settled on the most inconvenient one. Draco's jaw tightened, but he didn't respond. Mattheo caught the knut with a sharp snap.
Then she's somewhere else.
The implication hung in the air like smoke. Somewhere else meant with someone else. The thought settled over all three of them, and the fire chose that moment to crackle, spitting embers across the hearth.
Y/n Berkshire. Lorenzo's twin. She'd been there since first year, of course—quiet, watchful, untouchable in that way that made people wonder what it would take to make her crack. Every one of them had tried, in their own way. Draco with sneers that lingered too long. Theodore with silences that pulled like undertow. Mattheo with recklessness that always seemed aimed in her direction. It was a game none of them would admit to playing, but all of them were losing.
And then Mattheo, because he was Mattheo, spoke the thought none of them had ever said aloud.
leaning back on his hands, a slow smirk curling his mouth You know what I don't understand?
dryly Long division? Basic manners?
Why we're still pretending this is a competition.
Theodore's eyes finally lifted from his book. Not fast, but with the kind of deliberate focus that meant he'd been waiting for someone to say it. Draco's expression flickered—surprise, then something sharper, guarded.
And what, exactly, is it instead?
grinning, but there's no humor in it A waste. Three of us circling the same thing, getting in each other's way, and for what? So one of us wins? Please. She'd chew any one of us up and spit us out before breakfast.
voice dropping, cold Speak for yourself.
I am speaking for myself. And I'm saying I'm done with it. The game. The waiting. The pretending I don't notice when she walks into a room.
Silence. Even the fire seemed to dim. Draco's jaw worked like he wanted to argue, but Theodore was watching Mattheo with an expression that was unreadable and, for once, utterly still.
softly You're suggesting we share.
I'm suggesting we stop losing. his eyes flash She's not going to pick one of us. Not now. Not ever. But if we stop fighting each other and start paying attention to what she actually wants—he shrugs—maybe we stand a chance. All of us.
pushing to his feet, voice a blade That's the most ridiculous—
But he stopped. Because somewhere above them, a door creaked open.
Soft footsteps on stone. The faint rustle of fabric. The three of them turned, almost as one, toward the staircase to the girls' dormitories—and there she was. Y/n Berkshire, balanced on the last step, her shadow stretching long and flickering in the green-tinged firelight.
She looked like she always did. Composed. Unimpressed. Like she'd walked in on exactly the conversation she'd expected to find.