Secrets or Dare

Some secrets are better left hidden. Unfortunately, nobody gets to leave the game. A severe storm leaves Hogwarts flooded, trapping the Slytherin students together in their common room. With nothing better to do, Pansy suggests Truth or Dare. What begins as harmless fun soon turns into personal questions, awkward challenges, unexpected confessions, jealousy, and secrets coming to light. Nobody can skip a turn, and nobody wants to admit defeat. Between complicated relationships, hidden crushes, old arguments, and friendships full of tension, everyone has something to keep quiet. Especially you and Mattheo Riddle. Once inseparable and completely in love, you're now exes who pretend they can't stand each other. One stupid argument and too much pride ruined everything, but neither of you has moved on. His closeness with Lucinda, your jealousy, and all the feelings neither of you will admit make every interaction complicated. One game. Too many secrets. And a night that might change everything.

Created

550.8k

A miserable evening at Hogwarts, if ever there was one. Outside, the storm was doing its absolute best impression of the end of the world — rain lashing against the enchanted windows, wind howling through the flooded corridors, and the occasional distant rumble of thunder that made the candles flicker.

Inside the Slytherin common room, it was a different kind of storm. The kind made entirely of bored teenagers with too much ego and not enough entertainment.

The place was packed. Blaise had claimed his usual spot on one of the sofas, looking as unbothered as ever, while Daphne sat nearby, already deep in conversation with Pansy and Lucinda. The unholy trinity, as Valerie liked to call them. Their heads were bent together, voices low, eyes darting around the room — which was never a good sign.

Draco and Astoria were tucked into a corner, Astoria quietly reading while Draco sat close enough to make it very clear she was with him. Theodore and Octavian were on one of the window seats, talking quietly, Octavian's arm draped over the back of the cushions behind Theodore.

Lorenzo was making his rounds, chatting with anyone who'd listen, trying to keep himself entertained. Valerie and Icarus were practically on top of each other near the fire, bickering about something stupid in that way that made everyone roll their eyes.

And Aurelia was with you, leaning against the arm of the sofa, watching the room with the lazy amusement of someone who'd already judged everyone in it.

Aurelia Rosier

in a low, dry voice I give it another hour before someone starts a fight or Pansy starts crying. Maybe both.

Your guess was as good as hers. The evening had already stretched into that restless, aimless stage where everyone was bored out of their minds. Some people were on their phones, others were pretending to study, and a few were just staring at the ceiling like it might offer them something better to do.

Mattheo was with Icarus and the others, sprawled in a chair like he didn't have a care in the world. Except, of course, he did. Because Lucinda had somehow found yet another excuse to sit close to him — this time claiming she wanted to see something on his phone. Her hand was on his arm. Again. And he wasn't moving away. Of course he wasn't.

He was also, very irritatingly, aware of exactly where you were. You could feel it in the way his attention kept drifting, even when he was pretending to laugh at something Icarus said.

Valerie Selwyn

loudly, from her spot near the fire If I have to look at Lucinda touch Mattheo's arm one more time, I'm going to hex both of them.

Icarus Lestrange

deadpan You say that every ten minutes.

Valerie Selwyn

And I mean it every time.

The bickering continued, the storm kept howling, and the common room settled deeper into its collective boredom. And then, right on cue, Pansy sat up a little straighter, a familiar glint in her eye.

Pansy Parkinson

loudly, to the room at large I'm bored.

Lucinda Avery

without looking away from Mattheo We're all bored, Pansy. It's called being trapped in a dungeon.

Pansy Parkinson

Then let's do something about it.

She paused for effect, which was never a good sign. Then she smiled, slow and knowing.

Pansy Parkinson

Let's play Truth or Dare.

Theodore Nott

muttering Absolutely not.

Blaise Zabini

without looking up from his phone We're not twelve.

Daphne Greengrass

snorting That's desperate, even for you, Pansy.

Pansy Parkinson

rolling her eyes Oh, I'm sorry, I didn't realize you'd all rather sit here staring at the walls. Very mature.

Lucinda Avery

smirking It's a bit childish, isn't it?

Pansy Parkinson

shrugging Only if you're boring. Or scared. But I get it. Some people can't handle a little honesty.

The room went quiet for a beat. Pansy had that look — the one that said she knew exactly how to get under people's skin. And it was working.

Draco Malfoy

from his corner, dry You're really going to drag everyone into this?

Pansy Parkinson

What's the matter, Draco? Worried someone might ask you something you don't want to answer?

Draco's jaw tightened. Astoria placed a gentle hand on his knee without looking up from her book, a silent, practiced calm.

Lorenzo Berkshire

grinning I mean... it could be fun. Better than sitting here.

Octavian Rowle

flatly It's going to end in someone hexing someone else.

Pansy Parkinson

See? Everyone's already invested.

The idea was catching, whether people wanted it to or not. Because nobody wanted to be the one who backed down. The one who was too boring. Too scared. That was the trick, wasn't it?

the room shifts, people glancing at each other, waiting for someone to make the first move

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy