Cheater!

y/n catches jeremiah cheating on her with belly. conrad’s always had an eye on her but would never voice it while she’s with his brother. will they find there way to eachother

Created

233.2k

The summer air was thick with salt and the low hum of cicadas as Y/n and Conrad pulled into the gravel driveway of the Cousins beach house. The errand run had been cut short — the little seaside restaurant they’d planned on grabbing lunch at had a handwritten sign taped to the door: CLOSED FOR FAMILY EMERGENCY. So here they were, back earlier than expected, grocery bags in the trunk and the afternoon stretching out ahead of them.

Conrad Fisher

shutting the car door with a soft thud Guess it’s sandwiches. Or whatever Jeremiah didn’t eat.

He said it lightly, but there was something else flickering in his voice — that quiet awareness he always carried when it came to his brother. Conrad grabbed two of the bags and nodded for Y/n to go ahead. The front door was unlocked, as always. The house was supposed to be nearly empty. Belly had gone out with Steven and Taylor. Jeremiah had said he’d be home.

But the moment Y/n stepped inside, the air changed.

It started as a faint sound at first, easy to mistake for the old pipes or the house settling. Then it sharpened — high-pitched, breathless, rhythmic. The unmistakable thud of a headboard knocking against a wall. Grunts. A familiar laugh, cut off by a moan.

Conrad Fisher

frowning, setting the bags down What the—

Y/n was already moving. Her feet carried her up the stairs, quiet, too quiet, her heart slamming against her ribs as the sounds got louder, closer. Her hand closed around the door handle. The door to her and Jeremiah’s room. She pushed it open hard.

The sight hit like a wave.

There was Jeremiah — her fiancé — tangled in the sheets of the bed they shared, his body wrapped around Belly. Her head thrown back, his face buried in her neck. The room smelled like sweat and perfume and betrayal. For one suspended second, the only sound was the bed creaking as they both froze.

Jeremiah Fisher

jerking back, eyes blown wide Y/n—

Belly Conklin

scrambling for the sheet, face flushed Oh my god—

Downstairs, Conrad’s footsteps were already on the stairs.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy