𝒐𝒖𝒕 𝒐𝒇 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒈𝒓𝒂𝒗𝒆
Everyone thought Y/N was gone for good. Months later, she returns—and Mattheo Riddle is about to regret the night he chose someone else over the girl he loved.
Created
It was nearly midnight in the Slytherin common room, and somehow, the entire friend group had crammed themselves onto the same worn leather sofas despite there being plenty of space elsewhere. Old habits, I suppose. The green-tinted light from the Black Lake shifted lazily across the stone walls while a dying fire crackled with the enthusiasm of someone forced to attend a Monday morning class.
On the surface, everything looked normal. Lorenzo was sprawled across half a sofa, stealing crisps from an open bag that absolutely did not belong to him. Pansy was scrolling through something on her phone, occasionally shoving the screen toward Daphne with a dramatic roll of her eyes. Draco and Blaise were in the middle of some low-stakes argument about Quidditch that neither of them actually cared about. Astoria sat cross-legged on the floor, chin propped in her hands, watching everyone like she could keep them together through sheer optimism alone.
And Mattheo Riddle sat slightly apart from the rest, shoulders against the arm of the sofa, one hand spinning a silver ring around his finger. His gaze flickered toward the door every few minutes. He never mentioned it. Nobody asked. But everyone noticed.
without looking up from her phone Enzo, if you put your hand in that bag one more time, I'm hexing you.
mouth full It's basically ours. We share everything. It's the group bag.
That bag is mine.
Exactly. Thanks, mate. holds up a crisp like he's toasting him
scoffs You're actually disgusting.
grins He's not wrong, though. You did leave it out in the open. That's practically an invitation.
flatly That's victim blaming.
softly It really is.
Pansy finally looked up, tucking a strand of dark hair behind her ear. I could already tell she was about to make everything worse for someone. She had that look.
Since we're all here and being so fucking normal, can someone explain why Mattheo's been staring at the door like he's expecting a ghost to walk through it?
The room went a little too quiet. Theo's eyebrow rose. Astoria's smile flickered. Mattheo's hand stilled on his ring, but he didn't turn around.
quietly I haven't.
deadpan Right. And I haven't checked my reflection in four hours.
voice still low Drop it, Pans.
She didn't look like she wanted to drop it. Nobody did. But then Daphne touched Pansy's knee, a silent little signal, and Pansy exhaled sharply and looked back at her phone. Nice save. Barely.
leaning back It's late. We should probably head up soon.
immediately Or we could stay up and play something. Truth or dare. Never have I ever. Exploding Snap but we make it interesting.
It's almost midnight and you want to play party games?
Yes. Absolutely. Why, scared?
He's not scared. He just knows Pansy would pick dare and someone would end up in the lake.
smirking And? Sounds like a fun night.
Enzo, you have practice early tomorrow.
groans Daph, why would you remind me—
And just like that, the group slipped back into their usual bickering. Almost natural. But the laughter was a beat too late, and the jokes kept drifting back toward all the things nobody wanted to talk about. Mattheo still hadn't moved. His eyes had gone back to the fire, but his jaw was tight, and I'd bet anything his thoughts were somewhere else entirely.
It had been months now. Months of waiting for a message that never came, a door that never opened. They all pretended the group was the same, but the empty space was impossible to ignore. Some spaces were easier to fill than others. This one wasn't.
And Mattheo? He carried it all quietly, the way he did everything. The others could see something was wrong, but none of them knew the truth. Not yet, anyway.