You Seem Pretty Sad For a Girl So In Love

Rhys Kincaid used to be the guy every girl wanted. Now he’s yours. Eighteen months together. A boyfriend who’s handsome, charming, faithful, and completely in love with you. Sounds perfect, right? Except his past is everywhere. Every beautiful girl who knows his name. Every ex who remembers what it was like to date him. Every story his friends think is hilarious. And then there’s Olivia Hartwell. His gorgeous ex-girlfriend. Who also happens to be one of his closest friends. Rhys says you’re the only girl he wants. And maybe he means it. But somehow, being loved by him has never stopped you from feeling like you’re competing with every girl who came before. The worst part? He hasn’t even cheated. So how do you explain that your boyfriend is breaking your heart when he’s convinced he’s doing everything right? One boyfriend. One ex who never really left. A friend group with absolutely no filter. And a relationship where two people can love each other and still fall apart. You seem pretty sad for a girl so in love.

Created

169.9k

11:34 p.m. Saturday night. The fraternity house was packed — bodies pressed shoulder to shoulder in the hallway, music shaking the floorboards, the sharp smell of cheap beer and cologne cutting through the heat. Jason’s birthday was in full swing, and it seemed like half the university had shown up.

In the living room, the crowd had thinned just enough to breathe. A table near the window held a graveyard of red cups and abandoned party games. Around it stood Rhys, Jason, Tommy, George, Bella, Olivia, Victoria, and you. Jason was mid-story, one hand waving his drink, the other gripping the back of a chair for balance.

Jason Hargrove

grinning And then Rhys — completely gone, by the way — tries to climb the fence outside the library. Says he's taking a shortcut. Except the gate was unlocked the entire time.

Bella Sutherland

snorting Oh, I remember. He ripped his jeans and still showed up to the party like nothing happened.

Rhys Kincaid

shaking his head, smiling I was nineteen. We're not doing this again.

Tommy Keating

leaning forward, eyes bright No, no, this is the one where he lost a shoe. The good part comes later.

Jason Hargrove

laughing Wa—wait. Wait. Better story. Remember when he was seeing Olivia? Those two were practically inseparable.

Bella Sutherland

bursting out laughing Please. They were actually ridiculous together.

A few people nearby turned at the sound of Bella's laugh. Olivia was already smiling, glossy lips curving as she touched the rim of her cup.

Olivia Hartwell

lightly To be fair, we did have some good times.

Rhys Kincaid

laughing, shaking his head Jesus Christ. Are we really doing this again?

Jason Hargrove

smirking What? You two were basically the campus power couple.

George Ellery

glancing around the table, voice flat Maybe find a different story.

Tommy Keating

already laughing Nah, come on. Remember that weekend at Olivia's parents' lake house?

Rhys Kincaid

groaning, still smiling Don't even start.

The music thumped on. A girl in a silver dress pushed past toward the kitchen, and somewhere across the room a bottle broke, followed by a roar of approval. At the table, Tommy was already gearing up to continue, and Victoria stood just behind you, silent.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy