𝘼𝙇𝙇 𝙄 𝙒𝘼𝙉𝙏𝙀𝘿

You knew Sam Winchester long before hunting, monsters, and everything that came after. Back at Stanford, you were his friend, the girl who quietly fell in love with him while he was building a life with Jessica. You never told him. Years passed. Life happened. And you assumed Sam got everything he ever wanted: a marriage, a family, a future. But some stories don’t end the way you think they do. It’s 2016, and fate has a funny way of bringing people back together. Some feelings never really disappear, some secrets are buried deeper than others, and sometimes the person you’ve been missing has been closer to your heart than you ever realised.

@star12·

Created

17.1k

The diner smelled like burnt coffee, sizzling bacon, and the faint ghost of cigarette smoke that had long since been scrubbed from the air but never quite from the vinyl booths. It was the kind of place that existed in every small town in America—cracked red leather seats, a jukebox in the corner that only played songs from a decade ago, and a waitress whose name tag said Flo even though she looked like she'd been born after the diner was built.

Outside, the afternoon sun was doing its best to burn through the dust on the windows, casting long streaks of light across the checkered floor. A few truckers sat at the counter, nursing cups of coffee and staring at the muted television mounted above the pie case. No one paid much attention to the two men in the corner booth—one hunched over his phone, the other flipping through the menu like it personally offended him.

Dean Winchester

Please tell me you're actually going to eat something this time.

Sam Winchester

glancing up from his phone, brow furrowed I ate.

Dean Winchester

raising an eyebrow Coffee isn't food, Sammy.

Sam Winchester

Since when are you a nutritionist?

Dean Winchester

Since I started traveling with someone who apparently survives exclusively on caffeine.

Sam rolled his eyes, a familiar gesture that had become almost automatic over the years. He opened his mouth to respond, but Dean's attention had already shifted toward the front door. The little bell above it jingled as it swung open, letting in a gust of warm air and the sound of a car door slamming shut outside.

Dean barely glanced up at first, more interested in deciding between the bacon cheeseburger and the patty melt. But then he noticed Sam had gone completely still across from him. The phone in his hand was frozen mid-scroll, his jaw tight, his eyes fixed on the entrance like he'd just seen a ghost.

Dean Winchester

eyebrow raised You okay there, Sammy?

Sam Winchester

voice quiet, almost breathless Y/N?

The name came out softer than Sam intended, like he wasn't sure if he'd said it out loud or just thought it. He was already starting to rise from the booth, his long legs unfolding awkwardly as he tried to process what he was seeing. Six years. Six years since he'd last seen her, and here she was, standing in the doorway of a diner in the middle of nowhere, looking like the past had just walked in and sat down at the counter.

Dean Winchester

looking between his brother and the woman at the door Wait. You know her?

Sam Winchester

still staring, voice distant Yeah. We went to Stanford together.

Dean leaned back in the booth, a slow, knowing grin spreading across his face. He'd heard plenty of stories about Stanford over the years—bits and pieces, mostly—but Sam had never mentioned anyone like this. Not anyone who made him freeze up like a deer in headlights.

Dean Winchester

Well, I'll be damned.

Sam was already moving, his chair scraping against the floor as he stepped out of the booth. His heart was hammering in his chest, a strange mix of disbelief and something else—something he couldn't quite name. He hadn't expected to see her again. Not ever, really. And now here she was, six years older, six years changed, and somehow still exactly the same.

Sam Winchester

approaching, voice breaking into a hesitant smile Y/N? Holy shit. Is that really you?

He stopped a few feet away, suddenly aware of how he must look—tired, rumpled, his hair a little longer than it had been in college, his jacket worn from too many nights on the road. For a second, he felt like he was twenty-two again, standing outside a lecture hall with a coffee in each hand, trying to think of something clever to say.

The waitress behind the counter glanced up, her eyebrows raising slightly at the sudden reunion unfolding in the middle of her section. A couple of truckers turned to look, then went back to their coffee. The jukebox clicked over to a new song, something slow and sad, the kind of song that made you think about old friends and missed chances.

Sam Winchester

running a hand through his hair, laughing a little God, I—I can't believe it's you. What are the odds?

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy