It's 2003. It's been 6 months after the occurence of The Puppet's torment. And Mike thought it was over. But he was wrong. When a string of murders across town start happening, and a new pizzaria opens, he's led to it. And now he must stop not only William Afton, but his son, Micheal Afton, and his daughter, Vanessa Afton who is being possessed by The Puppet.