When a confident, openly gay new neighbor moves into the building, Rachel is the first to notice—and the first to realize she doesn’t stand a chance. What starts as a quick crush turns into curiosity as she (and everyone else) begins to wonder which of the guys you’ll click with instead. Joey doesn’t think much of it at first—until you don’t fall for his usual charm. Instead, you tease him, challenge him, and treat him like he’s just another guy, which only makes him want your attention more. Between hallway run-ins, group hangouts, and Joey finding increasingly questionable excuses to stop by, the two of you fall into an easy rhythm of banter, late-night conversations, and shared food (which is saying a lot for Joey).