Winning the contest feels unreal—until Claudia Jessie and Nicola Coughlan are standing in your living room, laughing over tea like old friends. What begins as a once-in-a-lifetime meet-and-greet turns into something warmer, something personal. They notice your necklace first—the delicate chain you’ve worn for years—and mention, almost offhandedly, that Luke Newton wears the exact same one.