The Audacity || M.R. • T.N. • D.M.

Mattheo Riddle and Theodore Nott have a problem: they’re secretly seeing the same person. Draco Malfoy has a bigger problem: he’s about to discover he’s the third idiot in this arrangement.

Created

95.5k

Thursday evenings in the Slytherin common room were usually uneventful. A few students scattered across the leather sofas, some pretending to study, others not bothering to pretend at all. The fire crackled low in the hearth, casting long shadows against the stone walls.

Tonight, however, was shaping up to be anything but quiet.

Theodore Nott stood near the center of the room, arms crossed, jaw tight. Across from him, Mattheo Riddle looked like he was two seconds away from throwing a punch at his best friend.

Theodore Nott

You've been sleeping with Y/N.

voice low, dangerously calm My Y/N.

Mattheo Riddle

laughs, sharp and humorless Your Y/N? That's fucking rich, mate. They've been mine for weeks.

Theodore Nott

Weeks? That's cute. I've been seeing them for months.

Mattheo Riddle

freezes ...What?

Theodore Nott

cold smile You heard me.

Mattheo Riddle

You're lying.

Theodore Nott

Do I look like I'm lying?

The tension between them snapped tight as a bowstring. A few first-years lingering near the far bookshelf exchanged nervous glances and quickly gathered their things, wisely deciding to vacate the premises.

Blaise Zabini

from the sofa, book open in his lap Oh, don't mind me. This is the most entertainment I've had all week.

Mattheo ignored him entirely. His fists were clenched at his sides, and his gaze was fixed on Theo with the kind of intensity usually reserved for the Quidditch pitch.

Mattheo Riddle

Months. You've been seeing them for months, and you didn't think to mention it?

Theodore Nott

scoffs Why would I? You're my best friend, not my diary.

Mattheo Riddle

Best friend. Right. Some fucking best friend you are.

Theodore Nott

Don't turn this on me. You're the one who went after someone I was already involved with.

Mattheo Riddle

How was I supposed to know?!

Theodore Nott

Perhaps by using that thing between your ears for something other than hitting Bludgers.

Mattheo took a step forward, and for a moment it looked like the argument might turn physical.

Then the portrait hole swung open.

Draco Malfoy

stepping into the common room, immaculate as ever What in Salazar's name is going on in here?

glances between them, then at Blaise I could hear you two from the corridor.

Mattheo Riddle

rounding on him Perfect timing, Malfoy. You'll never guess what I just found out.

Draco Malfoy

already looking bored I'm sure I won't.

Theodore Nott

voice sharp Save the dramatics for someone who cares, Riddle.

Mattheo Riddle

ignoring Theo, stabbing a finger toward the floor Theodore Nott has been sleeping with my person.

The words landed like a hex.

For a moment, Draco didn't move. Then—

Draco Malfoy

Your person?

Mattheo Riddle

pacing now, agitated My person. Y/N. The one I've been seeing for weeks. Apparently, I've been sharing them with this absolute prick the entire time.

Theodore Nott

coldly I had them first.

Draco Malfoy

voice dropping You had them first.

Theodore Nott

Yes, Draco. That's what I said. Do keep up.

Draco's jaw tightened. It was subtle—barely a flicker—but Theodore caught it. And Mattheo, despite his current state of fury, was not an idiot.

The room went very, very still.

Mattheo Riddle

slowly turning to face Draco fully Malfoy.

Why do you look like someone just stepped on your grave?

Draco Malfoy

voice clipped I don't know what you're talking about.

Theodore Nott

eyes narrowing Yes, you do.

A beat of silence. Then another. The fire crackled.

Mattheo Riddle

dangerously quiet Do you know Y/N?

Draco Malfoy

stiffly Everyone knows Y/N.

Theodore Nott

That's not what he asked.

Blaise Zabini

turning a page, not looking up This is better than the wireless.

Draco's hand twitched at his side—the only crack in his carefully constructed composure. Mattheo saw it. Theo saw it. The air in the room grew thick enough to choke on.

Mattheo Riddle

voice rising Draco. Do you know Y/N?

Silence.

Then, very quietly—

Draco Malfoy

For months.

The words hung in the air like smoke.

Mattheo Riddle

explodes I'M SORRY, WHAT?!

Theodore Nott

staring at Draco like he's never seen him before You've been seeing Y/N for months.

Months.

Draco Malfoy

pinching the bridge of his nose Lower your voice, you absolute—

Mattheo Riddle

You— pointing wildly between Draco and Theo —and you— and then at himself —and me?!

We've all been seeing the same fucking person?!

Blaise snapped his book shut with a sound like a gunshot.

Blaise Zabini

beaming Oh, this is magnificent.

Draco Malfoy

through gritted teeth Shut up, Blaise.

Blaise Zabini

unbothered Not a chance.

The shouting resumed almost immediately—three voices crashing over each other in a storm of accusations, insults, and increasingly creative profanity. The few remaining students in the common room fled. Even the portraits looked scandalized.

Then the portrait hole swung open once more.

Tom Riddle

pausing in the doorway, taking in the scene with cool detachment What the hell is going on?

His gaze swept across the room—his brother red-faced and gesturing wildly, Theodore Nott looking seconds away from murder, Draco Malfoy staring at the ceiling as though praying for patience. And Blaise Zabini, still seated, looking utterly delighted.

Tom Riddle

to Blaise Explain.

Blaise Zabini

grinning Oh, you're going to love this.

Blaise told him. With the enthusiasm of a man recounting the finest gossip of the century. He left nothing out—the reveal, the accusations, the way Draco's face had gone pale when Y/N's name was spoken aloud.

Tom listened without interruption, his gaze drifting toward the three men still arguing in the middle of the room. Then, ever so slightly, the corner of his mouth lifted.

It was practically a smile.

Tom Riddle

settling onto the sofa beside Blaise, looking entirely too comfortable How unfortunate.

Blaise Zabini

glancing at him Oh, you're enjoying this.

Tom Riddle

Immensely.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy