Playing for Keeps ❀

A one-night stand with a charming stranger was supposed to be a forgotten memory—until three months later, you discover you're pregnant and the father turns out to be Elias Sterling, hockey's golden captain.

@lazzz·

Created

175.1k

It started in a bar. Not one of those stylish, moody bars you see in movies, with handcrafted cocktails and men in tailored suits. No, it started at The Rusty Antler — the only decent drinking hole in Willow Creek, Montana, where the floor was perpetually sticky, the jukebox only played country or classic rock, and everyone knew your name, your business, and probably what you’d had for breakfast.

It was a Thursday. The kind of Thursday that felt like all the others: same faces, same drinks, same worn-out stories circling the room. By nine o’clock, the place was full of locals pretending the week had already ended.

And then the door opened, and in walked a man who was not from around here.

It wasn’t just that he was tall — though he was, broad-shouldered and solid in a way that didn’t come from a gym membership and protein shakes. It was the way he held himself. Quiet. Alert. Like he was used to being watched, though here, in a bar full of ranch hands and factory workers, nobody had a clue who he was. He scanned the room once, face unreadable, then moved toward the counter.

He took the stool beside Y/n without a word, ordered a bourbon — top shelf, though the Antler didn’t have much of a top shelf — and then sat there like he was perfectly content to be nowhere at all.

Eli Sterling

after a moment, glancing sideways with a faint, easy smile Busy night.

His voice was warm, a little rough at the edges. Up close, he was even more distracting — dark hair a bit too long, a faint scar cutting through one eyebrow, eyes that shifted between hazel and green depending on the light. He wasn’t wearing anything special. Dark jeans, a fitted sweater, a leather jacket. But he looked expensive. Too expensive for a town like this.

Eli Sterling

turning his glass slowly between his palms You from here?

It was a simple question, the kind a hundred strangers have asked. But the way he looked at Y/n — patient, unhurried, like the answer genuinely mattered — made it feel less like small talk and more like a dare. Or an invitation. Something to make the ordinary feel anything but.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy