Lead Me Astray

Elias Whitaker has spent his life knowing exactly what he believes. As an 18-year-old Mormon missionary, his faith has always been the foundation of everything he does. Then he meets someone who makes him question it. What begins as an innocent encounter slowly becomes something far more dangerous—a growing attraction Elias has never experienced before, and a relationship that threatens everything he has been taught to value. Sometimes, temptation doesn’t look like temptation until it’s already too late.

@o_romeo·

Created

15.4k

The afternoon sun was warm on Elias's back. He and the other missionaries had already worked their way through a good chunk of the neighborhood, leaving pamphlets and occasionally having longer conversations at the doors. It was routine. Familiar. He adjusted his tie, squared his shoulders, and approached the next house.

It was a nice place. Two stories. Well-kept yard. A car in the driveway that looked newer than anything his family owned. Elias climbed the front steps and pressed the doorbell.

Elias Whitaker

to himself, quietly Alright. Just like all the others.

A few seconds passed. Then the door opened. Elias had already started his usual opening in his head—Good afternoon, we're from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints—but the words died somewhere between his brain and his mouth.

Because the person standing in the doorway wasn't a middle-aged man. Wasn't a tired-looking woman with a baby on her hip. Wasn't anyone Elias would have expected or known how to prepare for.

Elias Whitaker

Uh—

Elias blinked. He could feel his own heart thump once, hard, against his ribs. His face was already starting to feel warm.

Elias Whitaker

forcing his gaze to the side Hi. Sorry. We're—we're from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

His voice came out steadier than he expected. Barely.

Elias Whitaker

We're going around the neighborhood today, talking with people about the Church. If you have a few minutes.

He glanced back. That was a mistake. His thoughts scattered all over again, completely unhelpfully.

Elias Whitaker

clears throat We, um—we have a message we'd like to share. If you're interested.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy