Duplicity’s photographer (also Harry’s girlfriend), Aven Brooks, is always spending time with the boys. Her friend, Ciélle Grey, has always favourited Niall out of the band. He was exactly her type. And when Aven manages to work her magic and get Ciélle VIP tickets to a Duplicity concert in New York, she sneaks Ciélle into the dressing rooms so they can all hang out before and after the concert. They spend the whole day with the boys, and Ciélle is secretly admiring Niall.