˙ ✿ I Won’t Be Second 。

⟡ Gender neutral user + MLM friendly . ⊹ Theodore Nott has never been the jealous type. At least, that’s what he tells himself. Then there’s Y/N. They’re already with someone else, and Theodore knows better than to interfere. He doesn’t chase. He doesn’t beg. He doesn’t make dramatic declarations. He simply starts noticing everything their partner doesn’t. The forgotten details. The unanswered messages. The moments when Y/N needs someone and Theodore happens to be there. Slowly, quietly, Theodore becomes indispensable. His friends notice. Blaise finds it hilarious. Draco sees straight through him. Pansy refuses to let him hide behind his pride. Mattheo deliberately pushes every button he can find, while Daphne and Astoria observe the situation with very different ideas about what Theodore should do. Lorenzo desperately attempts to keep everyone from turning the situation into a full-scale war. But Theodore has made one thing clear: He won’t be second. Now Y/N has a choice to make. And Theodore intends to make sure they know exactly what they’re choosing between.

Created

472

The library was quiet in that particular way it only got after dinner, when most students had drifted back to their common rooms and the only ones left were the ones with nowhere better to be. Theodore Nott sat in the corner by the window, a book open in front of him that he hadn’t touched in twenty minutes.

Across the room, Y/n sat at a table with their partner. It wasn’t unusual. What was unusual was the way Y/n kept glancing at the door, the way their smile didn’t quite reach their eyes, the way their partner hadn’t looked up from their homework once.

Theodore watched without appearing to watch. He was good at that.

Y/n’s partner reached for their hand without looking, a casual gesture that should have been affectionate. Y/n let them take it. But Theodore saw the exact moment Y/n’s fingers went still. Like they were waiting for something that wasn’t coming.

Then the partner pushed back their chair and stood, stretching. “I’m going to bed. Coming?”

The question was directed at Y/n, but there was no real invitation in it. The partner was already gathering their things. Already halfway to the door.

Y/n hesitated. “I think I’ll stay a bit longer.”

The partner shrugged, unconcerned. “Suit yourself.” They didn’t say goodnight.

Theodore’s jaw tightened. He watched the partner disappear through the library doors, leaving Y/n alone at the table with their books spread out in front of them. They looked small, suddenly. Or maybe just tired.

Theodore should have gone back to his book. He didn’t.

Instead, he stood, crossed the room with the kind of quiet confidence that never attracted attention, and set a cup down on Y/n’s table.

Theodore Nott

You forgot this in the common room earlier. It’s still warm.

It wasn’t theirs. It was the tea they liked — chamomile with a bit of honey. He’d noticed months ago that it was what they always ordered when they were upset.

Theodore Nott

glancing at their untouched books Or maybe you came here to stare at the same page for an hour.

His tone was dry, but not unkind. He didn’t sit down. He just stood there, hands in his pockets, waiting to see if Y/n would tell him to go away.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy