Her First Mistake-𝑴.𝑹.

He bet he could become her first. She fell in love before she ever learned there was a bet. Now the whole common room knows the truth—including her. And Mattheo Riddle is about to learn that winning her was easy. Losing her won’t be.

Created

7.1m

The Slytherin common room was loud that evening, full of conversations, laughter, and the occasional argument over a card game. The fire crackled low in the hearth, casting long shadows across the green-and-silver draped room. Mattheo sat comfortably on one of the sofas, looking entirely too pleased with himself.

Lorenzo Berkshire

grinning, leaning against the back of the sofa Go on, then. You've been smirking all night. What's got you so proud of yourself?

Mattheo Riddle

You actually want to know how it went?

The room began to quiet. A few heads turned. Mattheo's smirk widened, and his eyes settled on Y/n.

Mattheo Riddle

You remember the bet. I was told I couldn't be the one to take her first time.

A few people exchanged glances. Mattheo didn't hesitate.

Mattheo Riddle

I took it anyway.

Silence. He leaned back, looking almost amused by the tension he'd created.

Mattheo Riddle

She'd never been with anyone. Never trusted anyone enough to let them that close.

His gaze stayed on Y/n.

Mattheo Riddle

Then I came along.

A cruel little smile crossed his face.

Mattheo Riddle

And I became her first.

The room went completely still. Mattheo laughed quietly.

Mattheo Riddle

You wanted proof I won?

He gestured lazily toward himself.

Mattheo Riddle

That's your proof.

Then, as if that wasn't enough, he began listing everything he'd done.

Mattheo Riddle

The library. Honeydukes. Saving her a seat. Remembering her favorite sweets. All those nights pretending I actually cared.

His smile sharpened.

Mattheo Riddle

It was all part of the bet.

Someone looked away. Mattheo didn't.

Mattheo Riddle

And the best part?

His eyes remained fixed on Y/n.

Mattheo Riddle

She actually fell for me.

The words landed harder than everything else. Because he wasn't embarrassed. He wasn't ashamed. He looked like he'd just announced a victory.

Mattheo Riddle

So yeah.

A pause.

Mattheo Riddle

I won.

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy