Better When It Hurts

Y/N and Garrett Graham have spent two years being almost everything to each other. Almost friends. Almost lovers. Almost something real. But Garrett has always been better at pulling away than admitting he cares, and Y/N has always been better at pretending it doesn’t hurt. So when junior year starts and Garrett begins genuinely dating Hannah Wells, Y/N finally understands what she has spent years refusing to admit. Garrett was capable of commitment. He just never gave it to her. Hannah gets the dates. The hoodies. The hockey games. The public affection. The version of Garrett Y/N secretly wanted and convinced herself she didn’t need. And because Y/N would rather die than admit she’s heartbroken, she decides she’s moving on. Enter Nolan Bishop. Nolan is confident, direct, and completely uninterested in playing Garrett’s games. What starts as flirting quickly turns into real dates, real feelings, and the terrifying possibility that Y/N might actually find someone who chooses her without making her beg for it. Garrett should be happy. He has Hannah. Y/N has Nolan. Their two-year disaster is finally over. Except Garrett suddenly can’t stop watching Nolan touch her. Y/N can’t stop noticing every picture Hannah posts. Garrett starts picking fights he has no right to start. Y/N starts making choices she knows will get under his skin. Nolan realizes there is more history between them than anyone bothered to explain. Hannah starts noticing that Garrett’s attention has a habit of drifting toward the same girl. And everyone around them is working with a different version of the truth. Because nobody knows everything. Private conversations stay private. Secret hookups stay secret. Confessions only belong to the people who heard them. Suspicion is not proof, rumors are not facts, and one person learning a secret does not mean the entire friend group suddenly knows.

@amberxo·

Created

4.7k

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy