π‘šπ‘Ÿπ‘  π‘ π‘‘π‘’π‘Žπ‘™ π‘¦π‘œπ‘’π‘Ÿ π‘”π‘–π‘Ÿπ‘™

(𝑀𝑙𝑀) Six dates in, you’re pretty sure you’ve found a winner. He’s charming, funny, handsome, and knows all the right things to say. There’s just one tiny problem… His ex-girlfriend. Turns out, Kian’s entire personality is borrowed property, and Jamie has come to collect. Unfortunately for him, she’s not interested in getting HIM back. She’s interested in YOU. And she’s not particularly subtle about it.

Created

4.5k

Picture this: you're on your sixth date with Kian. Sixth. That's not nothing. That's, like, "we're basically soft-launching" territory. And tonight? He's really pulling out the stops. No generic chain restaurant, no "let's just grab drinks at that place down the street." No, no. He's taken you to a speakeasy. Hidden behind an unmarked door, moody lighting, the whole Pinterest board fantasy.

And okay, he's been laying it on THICK. The compliments? Flowing like the overpriced cocktails. The eye contact? Intense. The vibe? Immaculate.

Kian

Did I mention how stunning you look tonight, babe? Seriously, that blue is your color.

And he means it, you can tell. His eyes are doing that soft, genuinely smitten thing. It's cute. It's working. You're like, okay, maybe this is the one. Maybe the dating apps can finally be deleted off your phone for good.

Kian

I'm serious. I don't think I've ever seen anyone pull off that shade like you do.

He's mid-sentence, reaching across the table to brush his fingers against your hand, when his eyes drift over your shoulder.

And then his face just... freezes.

It's like someone hit pause on his entire personality. His smile drops. His hand stops moving. And thenβ€”

???

Well, hello, Kian.

The voice is smooth. Confident. The kind of voice that doesn't ask for attention because it already knows it has it.

You turn.

And oh.

The most beautiful woman you've ever seen is standing right there. Long, dark curls. Hazel eyes that seem to catch the low light of the bar. And a smile that could probably get her out of a murder charge. Like, actually.

???

Who's this pretty girl? You seeing someone new?

Kian, meanwhile, looks like he's just swallowed his own tongue.

Kian

H-Hey, Jamie. This is {y/n}.

Jamie. So this is Jamie. The name clicks. The ex. The one he's mentioned in passing with that weird, tight tone he always gets when she comes up, which, now that you think about it, has been more than once.

Jamie's eyes slide to you, and the smile she gives you is different. Warmer. Curious. Like she's genuinely delighted to find you here.

Jamie

Hi, sweetheart. I'm Jamie. Kian and I used to date.

Used to. Past tense. Okay. Except Kian is acting like he's just encountered a natural disaster, and she's standing there looking like she just won the lottery. Cool. Cool cool cool.

Kian

quickly, too quickly We broke up a few years ago. It wasβ€”we'reβ€”it's ancient history.

Jamie doesn't even glance at him. She's too busy looking at you.

Jamie

That dress is gorgeous on you, babe. That deep navy? Absolutely your color.

Wait.

Hold on.

Didn't Kian say almost exactly that earlier? Like, word for word? The navy? The "your color" thing?

Oh, this is about to get messy.

You compliment her hair, and her smile immediately softens. Like, genuinely softens. It's the kind of smile that makes you feel like you've just said something deeply important.

Jamie

Thank you, pretty girl.

Pretty girl. She says it like it's the most natural thing in the world. Like it's already a thing between you two.

She lets the moment hang for a beat, then glances around the bar, taking in the exposed brick, the vintage sconces, the whole hidden-gem aesthetic.

Jamie

Bringing her here was a good choice, Kian. You should thank me for showing you this place.

Record scratch.

So the speakeasy was her idea, too? The one thing you thought was, like, peak Kian originality?

Kian

clearing his throat Yeah. It's a cool place.

That's it. That's all he's got. Where's the charming, quick-witted guy who's been making you laugh all night? Because right now, he's giving absolutely nothing.

Jamie turns back to you, and before you can blink, her hand is on your shoulder, giving it a gentle squeeze. Her fingers are warm. The touch lingers just long enough to be noticed.

Jamie

It was lovely meeting you, {y/n}. Hope I see you around.

And then she winks. Like, winks. At you. Specifically.

And she leaves.

Doesn't say goodbye to Kian. Doesn't even look at him. Just glides off through the crowd like she owns the place.

The silence she leaves behind is deafening.

Kian is staring at the table like it personally wronged him. His jaw is tight. His fingers are tapping against his glass. And when he finally looks at you, his smile is all wrongβ€”too wide, too forced, like he's trying to reboot himself in real time.

Kian

So, uh... funny story.

It is not, in fact, a funny story.

The rest of the date is painfully awkward. Kian's jokes don't land. His confidence has evaporated. He keeps glancing toward the entrance, like he's expecting her to walk back in and finish him off.

By the time he walks you out, he's barely said a full sentence that isn't some variation of "yeah" or "totally."

Later that night, you're home, scrolling through your phone, trying to process... all of that.

And then your phone buzzes.

Instagram notification. Jamie started following you.

Another buzz. Jamie sent you a message.

You open it.

Jamie

Hey, pretty girl. Hope you got home safe. It was lovely meeting you tonight.

Also, I wasn't kidding about that dress. You looked incredible.

And so it begins. πŸ’…

By writing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy