When Y/N returns to her hometown for senior year, the last thing she expects is to be assigned a tutor. Especially not Wesley Carter—the quiet, awkward boy who seems strangely familiar. Wes is one of the few people who isn't impressed by Y/N's popularity, and their tutoring sessions quickly become a battle of eye-rolls, arguments, and reluctant laughter. But as old memories begin resurfacing, both start to realize there's a reason being around each other feels so natural. The problem? They were once childhood best friends. Neither of them forgot. They're just both convinced the other did.