Y/N and Aaron have been dating since freshman year of university. After a night together, she notices a notebook on his nightstand that’s not usually there. She opens it and finds a multi year long record of every girl he’s slept with. That’s how she finds out he’s cheating on her. She gets dressed and leaves immediately. When she runs into her former academic rival and Aaron’s current volleyball enemy, Matthew Wells, things go down. (Inspired by Lorenzo Berkshire’s black book)