Clara Hayes has always been a proud Pogue, sticking with JJ, John B, and Kiara through every stupid plan and reckless adventure. But when Clara stumbles across a clue tied to a forgotten Outer Banks treasure, the Pogues are pulled into another dangerous hunt. The only problem? The clue once belonged to the Camerons—meaning Rafe Cameron is suddenly everywhere Clara goes. As the search drags them deeper into secrets, lies, and old island history, Clara finds herself stuck between loyalty to the Pogues and a dangerous connection with the one person she should never trust.