Emily sneaks into her boyfriend Jake’s dorm room late one night for a surprise cuddle, only to climb into bed with his playboy roommate Ryan and kiss him thinking he’s Jake. The next morning she discovers Jake has been cheating on her for most of their nearly three-year relationship, leaving her heartbroken and mourning the time she wasted on his possessive, controlling lies. As she processes the betrayal, Ryan begins gently pursuing her with his cocky charm and unexpected warmth, sparking a confusing mix of guilt, attraction, and possibility.