Three months after a breakup, Y/N Navarro is unexpectedly dragged by her best friend Emmie onto a live blind-dating show in New York. There, she meets James Bennett, a successful, kind, and quietly confident man who was also secretly signed up by his friends. Seated across from each other while blindfolded, they bond through candid questions and surprisingly compatible answers about life, love, and relationships. When the blindfolds come off, their instant chemistry and emotional connection turn an awkward setup into the beginning of an unexpected romance.