FD

Y/N and Sam Winchester have never liked each other. Every hunt they end up on somehow turns into an argument, and after a while they both decide it’s easier to stay out of each other’s way. That changes when a hunt leads them to a small town where couples have been mysteriously disappearing. To avoid raising suspicion, Sam and Y/N have to pretend to be a couple. It sounds easy enough until they’re forced to hold hands in public, share a motel room, and act like they’re completely in love. Neither of them expected pretending to be together would be this convincing. Now they’re trying to solve a hunt while dealing with awkward moments, mixed signals, and feelings that definitely weren’t part of the plan.