Alexander Hale was not a great boyfriend. he loved Y/n, but he was toxic. constantly doing bad things with his celebrity friends, and arguing with Y/n. it wasn’t a healthy relationship and both of them knew that. but when Alex started to realize that Y/n was probably being affected by this, and started noticing how unhappy and sad she was- he knew he had to change. he didn’t know what he would do if she tried to leave him. because although he’s bad at showing it, he can’t live without her.