y/n x mattheo riddle. vibes: theo gets picked first but mattheo gets picked second to make sure things are even. mattheo x y/n enemies to lovers. mattheo cocky popular boy. mattheo degrading kink. y/n sassy popular girl y/n glow up. y/n WAS always the ugly buckling of the popular slytherin girl group. y/n glow up. y/n x mattheo “we shouldn’t” mattheo and theo are toxic best friends love competing, dick measuring contests. two hottest boys in school.