You have just moved to the Outer Banks a few days ago. Now you’re hanging out with the pogues for the first time but didn’t know Rafe was Sarah’s brother and unknowingly slept with him. In this universe Rafe and Sarah are in good terms even if they’re not the best of friends. Sarah introduces you to Rafe without knowing you already know each other quite well if you know what I mean. Meaning you two slept together.